This morning, DHS Commissioner Cal Ludeman announced that people currently on GAMC will be automatically transferred to MinnesotaCare. In transitioning people from GAMC to MinnesotaCare, Gov. Pawlenty’s administration has laid to rest one of the DFL’s accusations, that his unallotments would create thousands of new uninsured people.
Meanwhile, Sen. Linda Berglin is already whining about the Pawlenty administration’s decision:
Sen. Linda Berglin, DFL-Minneapolis, who chairs the Health and Human Services Budget Committee, said MinnesotaCare is already stretched because the economy has resulted in a surge of new enrollees. Add the General Assistance enrollees and the program is likely to run out of funding in 2011 instead of 2012, she said.
Sen. Berglin acts as though the only choice is to raise taxes and refill the account from which MinnesotaCare is paid out of. Sen. Berglin knows that that isn’t the only option because she’s been briefed on Rep. Steve Gottwalt’s Healthy Minnesota Plan, which would save tens of millions of dollars if implemented.
This is why we need a new majority party in the legislature. Reps. Tom Huntley and Paul Thissen have both been impressed with Rep. Gottwalt’s plan. According to the committee minutes for March 25, Rep. Gottwalt’s bill passed. In fact, the bill passed unanimously:
REP. GOTTWALT’S HEALTH CARE REFORM INITIATIVE UNANIMOUSLY PASSES COMMITTEE
ST. PAUL - State Rep. Steve Gottwalt, R-St. Cloud, today presented a health care reform bill (HF1865) that would improve how Minnesota provides health care coverage to low-income adults, while saving the state an estimated $100 million per year.
Gottwalt presented the Healthy Minnesota Plan (HMP) to the Health Care and Human Services Policy and Oversight Committee, which unanimously approved the bill, moving it on to the Health and Human Services Finance Division.
The HMP would cover 84,000 Minnesota adults currently on MinnesotaCare with a more generous private market benefit package, and a deductible covered mostly by the state. The plan would pay providers market rates for the health care they deliver, eliminating cost-shifting, and opening more health care access to those enrolled in the plan.
The HMP would save state administrative costs, provide greater flexibility for the enrollee, tap into savings of large private insurance pools, and fit well with other health care reform initiatives. Gottwalt described the bill as a “demonstration project that will improve care for 84,000 Minnesotans, and save the state about $200 million in the coming biennium.”
“The plan benefits consumers, providers and the state,” Gottwalt said. “Even if Minnesota were not facing a huge budget deficit, we need to explore better ways of covering more Minnesotans in a manner that is financially sustainable and engages consumers more directly. The private market can deliver better access to high quality, cost-effective health care.”
Gottwalt said Minnesota currently spends about $7,000 per year for every adult enrollee on MinnesotaCare. He said conservative estimates show the HMP will save the state more than $1,000 per adult enrollee, or about $100 million per year ($200 million per biennium).
“The savings actually grow over time,” Gottwalt said. “We think this approach could be used to provide coverage to other public enrollees, saving even more.” Given the current state budget deficit, this is seen as a sustainable way to provide coverage to people in need while saving the state significant money.
Gottwalt said the HMP generates state savings several ways, starting with tapping into larger, private insurance pools to capitalize on more efficient administrative, education and enrollee services now provided by the state.
Also, the cost to the state for covering most of the deductible under the HMP is based on actual expenditures, not a per-member-per-month capitation payment. The Healthy Minnesota Plan Account (structured as a Health Reimbursement Account or HRA) requires the state to maintain a reserve, but not full funding up front. HF1865 does not include copays, but it is structured to be flexible in addressing cost sharing issues.
The HMP offers an even greater level of benefits than currently available under MinnesotaCare, including dental, vision and pregnancy coverages. The plan provides first-dollar coverage of primary and preventive care, all the covered benefits of MinnesotaCare, and a $5 million lifetime maximum (much stronger than MinnesotaCare’s $10,000 inpatient maximum).
“Instead of being denied access to care by providers who do not get paid enough from existing Minnesota public programs, these enrollees will now be considered on par with other privately insured people,” Gottwalt said. “Also, these enrollees will have a debit card with which to pay eligible expenses within the deductible. No more being shunned for lack of a cash co-payment or deductible payment. And, unlike
MinnesotaCare, the Healthy Minnesota Plan major medical coverage is completely portable; it belongs to the enrollee.”
According to the meeting’s minutes, here are the DFL legislators who voted for HF1865:
Paul Thissen, Tina Liebling, Julie Bunn, Patti Fritz, Paul Gardner, Jeff Hayden, Tom Huntley, Carolyn Laine, Diane Loeffler, Erin Murphy, Kim Norton, Maria Ruud and Cy Thao
It’s time that people asked Sen. Berglin why she hasn’t scheduled a hearing on Rep. Gottwalt’s legislation. For that matter, why didn’t the Health Care and Human Services Finance Division didn’t give Rep. Gottwalt’s bill a hearing and an up-or-down vote.
The Health Care Access Fund is quickly drying up, which means that people are kicked off the state plan as required by state law when health care programs run out of money. Sen. Berglin is insisting that we raise taxes so they can keep doing things the same way.
For Minnesota’s taxpayers, I demand to know why Sen. Berglin refuses to reform this important programs and save Minnesota’s taxpayers millions of dollars annually.
Based on her obstructionism, it’s accurate to say that Sen. Berglin needs a lesson in ‘You Work For Us’ public servantship. If she continues resisting money-saving reforms on one of the state’s biggest ticket items, then we have the right to ask why.
It’s equally clear that Sen. Berglin needs her status changed from Chairlady to Ranking Member starting in 2011. Minnesota simply can’t afford Sen. Berlin’s obstructionism and pig-headedness. It’s costing Minnesota taxpayers millions and millions of dollars. It’s providing an inferior product.
It’s time we dragged Sen. Berglin kicking and screaming into the 21st Century. We don’t work for her. She works for us. If she won’t do what’s best for Minnesota, then we’ll find someone who will. We can’t afford 2 more years of status quo ‘leadership’, It’s too expensive.
It’s time to change from a one-size-fits-all leadership to an innovative, reform-minded leadership. Sen. Berglin, unfortunately, represents the expensive status quo DFL leadership. What we need is the type of reform-minded leadership that Rep. Gottwalt embodies.
To do otherwise is foolish and expensive.
Technorati: GAMC, MinnesotaCare, Healthy Minnesota Plan, Reforms, Steve Gottwalt, Cal Ludeman, GOP, Linda Berglin, Status Quo, Tax Increases, Obstructionists, DFL, Election 2010
Entries RSS2 Feed
Comments RSS2 Feed
Proud C.C. Contributing Editor
Is it cost shifting by Pawlenty to the counties? I do not recall the source, but I did see that characterization online. Without knowing how that dimension would play out, I could only speculate.
Gary, do you know an answer?
Comment by eric z. • 11Nov2009 @ 6:11 am
PiPress, reported, this link [quoted between the dotted lines]:
http://www.twincities.com/health/ci_13733270
………………
But Democrats reacted swiftly to the move, arguing that it may not be a long-term solution for about 35,000 patients currently on General Assistance Medical Care, a $381 million program for those who make less than $7,800 annually that Republican Gov. Tim Pawlenty axed earlier this year in a cost-cutting move.
“This one-time action provides the greatest benefit to enrollees and maintains their health care coverage,” Department of Human Services Commissioner Cal Ludeman said.
The GAMC program is expected to end around March 1, 2010. The program serves many people, often homeless and suffering from mental illness or chemical dependency, who show up at hospitals for care. Hospitals have warned that losing the program could have devastating effects on their balance sheets.
The loss of the program is especially troublesome to urban hospitals such as Hennepin County Medical Center in Minneapolis and Regions Hospital in St. Paul, which together provide a quarter of the charity care in the state. During the last week, for example, Regions saw 73 GAMC patients in the emergency room, treated 131 on an outpatient basis, saw 40 people with serious mental illness and performed emergency, same-day surgery on eight.
…………………..
It looks like Pawlenty being Pawlenty, and as such is no news to those disliking Pawlenty and the way the man operates.
Comment by eric z. • 11Nov2009 @ 6:17 am
Eric, transferring these people into MinnesotaCare gives the legislature time to pass Rep. Gottwalt’s Healthy Minnesota Plan, which would save state taxpayers a huge amount of money while improving MinnesotaCare & that would give people a private insurance policy. In other words, those least able to pay get taken care of & those who return to the workforce would have a low-cost insurance policy that is portable.
In fact, the insurance company that wrote this policy would likely market the policy if Pelosicare wouldn’t ban it because it didn’t meet their mandates.
BTW, if Pelosicare passes, expect a whole group of states to band together & file a lawsuit rejecting the constitutionality of imposing a mandate to buy insurance. The states are getting tired of the government making policy where it doesn’t have the constitutional authority to set state policy. They’re especially tired of having the Obama administration set state policy through the stimulus bill.
Comment by Gary Gross • 11Nov2009 @ 6:31 am
Pawlenty wimped out again. Remember the “people” on GMAC are non-citizen HOBOS that don’t get GMAC in ANY state in the U.S.A. That’s why you see these “homeless” everywhere here and nowhere else in this country. Their coming here for the WELFARE!!!
Comment by JPL • 11Nov2009 @ 9:17 am
Sen. Berglin can’t take any action on the bill since 1) it’s not session 2)it’s not in her committee.
As to GAMC it’s just the Governor continuing to pass the buck and ignore the long-term problems our state faces. He reminds me of the 70’s rock star who trashes the hotel room and then runs away while others have to clean it up.
Leadership and responsibility are two things he does not possess.
Comment by Kurt Neider • 12Nov2009 @ 8:40 am
Kurt, You’d be better off if you had the facts right. Gov. Pawlenty likes the Healthy Minnesota Plan so much that it’s been part of his reform agenda since it was proposed. Adopting HMP would’ve saved a ton of money. That, in turn, would’ve been used to provide people on GAMC with health care.
THAT’S CALLED LEADERSHIP & INNOVATION!!!
It’s also something that the DFL frowns on. Time after time after time, I’ve watched Gov. Pawlenty or GOP legislators propose reforms, only to watch the DFL defeat the reforms on party line votes.
1) She ignored it when they were in session. 2) She was briefed by Steve about the bill last year. She had the opportunity to co-sponsor the bill. Obviously, she didn’t co-sponsor the bill. Had she co-sponsored it, she could’ve given it a hearing in the Health and Human Services Budget Division THAT SHE CHAIRS!!!
If you have any other flimsy excuses you want to offer for Sen. Berglin’s obstructionism, lert me know. I’ll be happy to demolish them like I demolished these flimsy excuses.
Comment by Gary Gross • 12Nov2009 @ 11:01 am
[...] Pawlenty acts; Berglin whines, refuses to enact important reforms, Let Freedom Ring [...]
Pingback by » Morning Report 11/11/2009 • 02Dec2009 @ 4:07 pm